Travis Hazlewood: How to Market Through the Three Stages of AI in the Inbox
Today’s guest post comes from Travis Hazlewood. Travis has spent 7 years in email deliverability and leads a deliverability team at Ortto (a Canva company). He writes Inboxicated, a LinkedIn newsletter about earning the inbox, then earning more in it. Take it away, Travis!
It’s 9am on a Monday morning. The coffee hasn’t hit yet. I open my work email and decide to use Google’s new AI Inbox feature to get a head start on what would otherwise be a mental-burial of pharaonic proportions.
And this is what Gemini offered up:
1 to-do, 2 topics I should catch up on, and (by implication) 3,000 other unread emails I can continue to ignore.
(AI Inbox is still a paid, US-only feature for now. But it shows exactly where AI in the inbox is heading.)
We, email marketers, have spent the last few decades turning people’s mailboxes into junk pyramids, and mailbox providers have finally taken it upon themselves to give users their mailboxes back by digging out the treasures for them.
So if we’re going to keep enjoying what email marketing pays out, we’re going to have to stop tossing junk on top of the pile and find a way through these new features to our subscribers…
Our ability to inbox and to earn revenue both depend on it.
And that starts with understanding that AI is interrupting marketers and their subscribers in three distinct stages.
Stage 1: AI interrupts your pitch
Outside of connecting your favorite AI to your email, every major mailbox provider has been shipping AI features that change what your subscribers see before they ever open.The most common is a summary or extraction replacing things like:
- Preview text (Apple, Yahoo, Outlook*)
- Subject lines (Yahoo, where I’ve watched brand subject lines get swapped out for its own summary)
- Above-the-fold visibility via Deal Cards (Google, Yahoo)
- Above-the-fold visibility via ads (Google, Yahoo)
Much has already been said about these (including yours truly), but this is really just Stage 1.
At this stage, the user still scrolls the inbox the way they always have…but they’re seeing your email through AI’s eyes.
Stage 2: AI interrupts the casual scroll
This next stage takes the user away from browsing altogether:- Google’s new AI Inbox saves readers from the scroll-and-skim with to-dos and topic catch-ups in a clean, decluttered UX
- Yahoo’s new Planner (mobile app, US for now) scrapes details from life-admin emails and suggests to-dos to add to a calendar while Catch Up makes inbox clean-up so easy users don’t have to open an irrelevant message again, both via card-like interfaces outside the inbox
- Apple’s Priority Messages pulls time-sensitive emails to the top of the inbox for users who turn it on, so sending most recent no longer means landing at the top (bad news for Send-Time Optimization)
- Outlook’s Prioritize tags every new email as high, normal, or low priority and lets users filter down to just the high ones (and more bad news for STO)
Stage 3: AI interrupts the inbox completely
Claude and ChatGPT users are linking their accounts and letting their agents skim, summarize, draft, and even (in some cases) send without a user’s involvement.There’s no user in an inbox here. No design, subject line, etc. competing for a human’s attention by distracting them into a sale as they look for a particular email.
The agent scrapes your pitch through live-text, assesses urgency based on the user’s priorities (not the marketer’s), and decides whether your email is seen or not.
Strangely, inboxing becomes both more and less powerful because of this.
Landing in the inbox means less if you’re not one of the recipient’s priorities. And being one of their priorities means nothing if you’re in spam, because the agent isn’t going to dig through there for you.
At this Stage, the future of email marketing (and inboxing) runs through AI.
And since inboxing is still dependent on engagements, your email marketing strategy has to be ready to get your emails over more hurdles than ever before to earn that engagement.
Inboxing Through AI
With users moving away from the inbox, what are your priorities when eye-catching subject lines are invisible and cutting-edge designs are basically non-existent?Your emails are then reduced to the value and relationship offered in your content.
So to Inbox and be seen through the AI:
- You have to earn prioritization with your subscribers
- You have to earn it through a summary as much as your own designs
To earn prioritization, your emails will need to earn regular engagements AND create a curiosity that can’t be sated with a summary. Here’s how:
- Prioritize activity-triggered automations over general, bulk sending (where possible)
Stage 2 rewards what matters to that person right now, and an activity-triggered email is relevant by default - Use segmentation and/or dynamic content to promote via relevant interests
Prioritization happens per subscriber so your relevance has to be earned with each person - Focus on consistency and substance over flash and higher volume
Prioritization also has to be earned consistently to be maintained - Provide clean offers via live-text for your primary pitches
Summaries and agents don’t read hero images so if the offer only lives there the AI will summarize around it - Create a surprise-and-delight experience with your writing voice and secondary content
The path to getting your subscribers to actually look at your emails is through giving an experience they know is worth the effort of moving past the summary - Routinely test new content to understand AI-trends
Understanding trends increases your ability to work with the AI to earn prioritization
BONUS: Testing Through AI
Any good email marketer should have a testing strategy for their subscribers already in place.It’s time to add some testing for AI as well:
- See what AI does with your emails:
- Turn on Apple Intelligence if you have an iPhone 15 Pro or newer
- Use summary features where available with test addresses at relevant mailbox providers
- Hook up Claude, ChatGPT, etc. to test mailboxes and see what they do with it
- Ask questions for answers you can actually work with:
- Do the agents prioritize your email for inbox-wide summaries?
(set up a neutralized project/agent to protect from skewing tests) - Is there an unexpected trend that you could likely adjust for?
- Does it earn the payoff or show how flat the offer really is?
- Would you prioritize the email as a customer?
- If you removed the pitch that was summarized, would the rest of your content hold up on its own?
Control is futile but you can affect trends with a nudge here and there.
Close
Each mailbox provider and AI agent has its own custom algorithms so wrestling with each one is a no-win...But the most important signal they all rely on is the same: subscribers who keep engaging with your content.
As email evolves, AI is going to be the one digging through the pile either way.
Don’t toss another junk-stone on the pyramid. Make your emails the treasure worth excavating.
As email evolves, AI is going to be the one digging through the pile either way.
Don’t toss another junk-stone on the pyramid. Make your emails the treasure worth excavating.
